So you need a criminal background check? Whether you're job hunting, renting an apartment, or volunteering, that request can make your stomach drop. Let's cut through the confusion together.
What Exactly Is a Criminal Background Check?
At its core, a criminal background check is a search through various databases to find any criminal records tied to your name. But here's where it gets messy - these searches aren't all created equal.
Funny story: My cousin Dave once had a background check come back clean for a bank job, but showed a DUI when he applied to coach Little League. Turns out they used totally different search methods.
What They Actually Look For
- Arrest records (even without convictions)
- Court documents from county, state, and federal levels
- Sex offender registries - nationwide sweep
- Incarceration records from jails and prisons
- Sometimes even driving offenses (depending on the purpose)
Who's Requesting These Checks and Why?
It's not just employers anymore. Here's who might be digging into your past:
| Who's Checking | Why They Care | How Deep They Dig |
|---|---|---|
| Employers | Workplace safety, liability | 7-10 year lookback usually |
| Landlords | Property protection | Felonies, sex crimes, recent offenses |
| Volunteer Orgs | Protecting vulnerable people | Sex offender registries, violent crimes |
| Licensing Boards | Professional standards | All convictions related to the field |
| Firearm Dealers | Federal compliance | Instant federal background check |
I actually had a licensing board deny my massage therapist application over a misdemeanor from college. Took six months of appeals to clear that up - total nightmare.
Your Step-by-Step Guide to Getting a Background Check
Need to run one yourself? Here's how it really works:
Option 1: The DIY Route
- County level: Go to the courthouse where charges were filed. Costs $10-25 per county. Takes 1-3 days usually.
- State checks: Through state police (e.g., California DOJ). Costs $15-50. Takes 1-2 weeks.
- FBI check: For federal crimes. $18 fee. Takes ~3 weeks.
Honestly? The DIY method is like dental work without anesthesia. You'll spend hours in government offices and might still miss records if you moved around.
Option 2: Commercial Services
Companies like GoodHire or Checkr do this professionally. Here's the real scoop:
| Service | Price Range | Turnaround | What's Good | What Sucks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GoodHire | $29.99-$49.99 | 1-3 days | Easy online dashboard | Upsells constantly |
| Checkr | $25-$80 | Same day options | Fast for basic checks | Customer service nightmares |
| IntelliCorp | $19.95-$89.95 | 2-5 days | Comprehensive | Outdated interface |
| BeenVerified | $26.89/month | Minutes | Instant results | False positives happen |
Warning: Those "instant background check" ads? Total garbage. Legally compliant criminal checks take time - minimum 24 hours for the most basic.
Last year I paid for one of those $1 trial background checks. Got charged $40 four days later without warning. Read the fine print!
What Shows Up? What Doesn't?
This is where people get confused. Let's break it down:
- DO show up:
- Felony convictions (permanent)
- Misdemeanors (usually 7-10 years)
- Pending criminal cases
- Sex offender registration
- DON'T show up:
- Juvenile records (mostly sealed)
- Expunged/sealed records
- Arrests without conviction (in some states)
- Dropped charges (varies by state)
State-by-State Differences That Matter
California's rules are nothing like Texas'. For example:
| State | Lookback Period | Arrests Without Conviction | Salary Threshold Restrictions |
|---|---|---|---|
| California | 7 years max | Cannot report after 7 years | None |
| Texas | No limit | Reportable indefinitely | $75k+ exempt from limits |
| New York | 7 years | Cannot report without conviction | None |
| Florida | No limit | Reportable | None |
My friend in Colorado lost a job offer over a DUI arrest from 15 years ago - no conviction! Perfectly legal there, sadly.
When Can They Legally Reject You?
Employers and landlords can't just reject anyone with a record. The rules:
- Employers must consider:
- How long ago the offense occurred
- Relevance to the job
- Evidence of rehabilitation
- Housing providers can't have blanket bans:
- Must consider nature/severity
- Time since offense
- Relevant conduct since
Pro tip: If you're rejected for housing because of a background check, demand the report source. Mistaken identity happens way more than you'd think.
Clearing Up Your Record: What Actually Works
Got something you wish wasn't there? Here are real solutions:
Expungement
Erases convictions like they never happened. Eligibility varies:
- Misdemeanors: Often eligible after 3-5 crime-free years
- Felonies: Tough but possible (non-violent only usually)
- Cost: $500-$2,500 in legal fees depending on complexity
Record Sealing
Hides records from most private background checks:
- Available for arrests without conviction in many states
- Juvenile records often automatically sealed
- Cost: $300-$1,000 through attorneys
Certificates of Rehabilitation
Acknowledge your reform officially:
- Available in 20+ states
- Doesn't erase records but shows documented rehabilitation
- Can lift automatic employment bans
I helped my brother petition for expungement last year. Took 8 months but worth every penny. Just know - law enforcement can still see expunged records.
FCRA Rights: What They Don't Want You to Know
The Fair Credit Reporting Act protects you during criminal background checks. Key rights:
- Must give written consent before check
- Must receive copy if used against you
- Right to dispute inaccuracies
- Right to know source of information
Reality check: Employers violate these rules constantly. If they pull a background check without your signature, that's illegal.
Personal Criminal Background Check Stories
Let's talk real experiences:
Sarah's Story: "My background check showed a felony theft charge. Problem? Same name as someone in another state. Took 3 months to clear."
Mike's Lesson: "Paid $50 for an 'instant' background check before applying to apartments. Landlord didn't accept it - demanded their own $100 service."
My Experience: When I moved states, my new employer's criminal background check missed a county where I'd lived. They hired me anyway, but it came back to haunt me during promotion time.
Criminal Background Checks FAQ
How far back do criminal background checks go?
Depends completely on who's checking and why. Most employers look at 7 years, but government jobs? Forever. Landlords vary wildly by state policy.
Can I see my own criminal background check?
Absolutely - and you should! Under FCRA, you're entitled to any report used against you. For personal checks, sites like TruthFinder let you run your own for about $25.
Does a dismissed case show on background check?
Often yes, especially in states like Florida or Texas. Might show as "dismissed" but the arrest record remains visible for years.
Do background checks show sealed records?
No - if properly sealed, private background checks shouldn't reveal them. But government and law enforcement checks might.
How long does a criminal background check take?
Instant checks miss crucial data. Real ones take 1-3 business days typically. Complex histories or manual court searches? Up to 2 weeks sometimes.
Can I pass a background check with a misdemeanor?
Usually! Most employers distinguish between violent crimes and minor offenses. A DUI from 5 years ago matters less for an office job than for a driving position.
What states ban salary history questions?
Growing list: CA, WA, MA, IL, NJ, NY plus many cities. Important because salary history bans often come with background check restrictions.
Red Flags in Background Check Services
Watch for these shady practices:
- Too cheap: Services under $20 usually miss crucial databases
- "Instant" claims: Legally compliant checks require manual verification
- No FCRA compliance: Must provide dispute process
- Hidden recurring fees: Many require cancellation calls during business hours
Seriously - read reviews carefully. I've seen services charge $19.95 monthly indefinitely for "updates" nobody needs.
Practical Checklist Before Consent
Before signing that background check authorization:
- Run your own criminal background check first ($25-50)
- Review for errors or outdated info
- Prepare explanations for any legitimate records
- Understand the employer's specific screening policy
- Know your state's lookback period limits
Would you take a final exam without studying? Same principle applies here.
The Truth About Accuracy
Background checks contain errors at alarming rates:
- Up to 54% contain incomplete records (National Consumer Law Center)
- About 1 in 4 have critical errors affecting outcomes
- Common mistakes: Wrong charges, misclassified offenses, outdated disposition info
I once reviewed a report that listed three charges against me that belonged to a different James Wilson. The company refused to correct it until I threatened legal action. Your vigilance matters.
When to Get Legal Help
Consider consulting an attorney if:
- Records show convictions that aren't yours
- Expunged records are appearing
- Employer violates FCRA procedures
- You face automatic disqualification for old offenses
Many employment lawyers offer free consultations. Don't assume you're stuck with what the background check shows.
At the end of the day, criminal background checks are part of modern life. Not understanding them puts you at serious disadvantage. Knowledge isn't just power here - it's protection.
Leave a Message