So you're thinking about installing a tankless water heater? Smart move. I did this last year at my cousin's place and wow, what a difference from those clunky old tank heaters. But let's be real - the installation process can feel like solving a Rubik's cube blindfolded if you're not prepared.
Why Tankless? The Good, The Bad, and The Pricey
Endless hot showers sound great until your teenager takes a 45-minute shower and your gas bill looks like a mortgage payment. That's where installing a tankless water heater changes the game. These wall-mounted units heat water on demand instead of keeping 50 gallons hot 24/7. My neighbor Sarah switched last winter and saved nearly $200 on her first utility bill.
But it's not all roses:
- The upfront cost stings - Quality units start around $800
- Retrofitting older homes hurts - You might need electrical/gas upgrades
- Flow rates matter - Try running two showers and the dishwasher simultaneously and you'll see what I mean
Honestly? If you have more than 3 bathrooms or love running multiple hot water appliances, you might need two units. Don't make the mistake my buddy Dave did - his kitchen went cold every time his kids showered.
Electric vs Gas: The Real Cost Breakdown
| Factor | Gas Tankless | Electric Tankless |
|---|---|---|
| Unit Cost | $850-$1,500 | $550-$900 |
| Installation Complexity | Venting required (stainless steel pipes ain't cheap) | May need electrical panel upgrade ($1,200+) |
| Operating Cost (annual) | $180-$250 | $220-$350 |
| Lifespan | 20+ years | 15-18 years |
Gas wins long-term if your house already has gas lines. But that electrical upgrade for electric models? I've seen contractors charge $2,500 just for the panel work. Ouch.
The Installation Process: What They Don't Tell You
Installing a tankless water heater isn't like swapping out your microwave. There's actual plumbing and electrical work involved. Last month I watched a DIYer flood his garage because he skipped the pressure relief valve. Don't be that guy.
Must-Have Tools You'll Need
- Pipe cutter ($35 at Home Depot)
- Torch kit for soldering (rent at tool rental shops)
- Concrete drill bit (if mounting on brick)
- Voltage tester - please don't electrocute yourself
Seriously though, unless you've sweated copper pipes before, consider hiring a pro. The labor costs sting less than water damage repairs.
Placement Matters More Than You Think
Where you mount your unit affects everything:
- Keep it within 30 feet of main water intake
- Never install in attics that freeze (learned this the hard way)
- Leave 12 inches clearance around sides for maintenance
- Garage walls are ideal - easy access and drainage
Warning: Installing a tankless water heater too far from fixtures causes annoying delays. At my lake cabin, we wait 15 seconds for hot water because it's 50 feet from the bathroom. First world problems, I know.
Real Product Recommendations That Won't Fail
After installing dozens of these units, I've got opinions. Stay away from those suspiciously cheap Amazon brands - their heat exchangers crack within 2 years. These three actually deliver:
Rinnai RU199iN (Natural Gas)
The Mercedes of tankless heaters. Handles 3+ bathrooms without breaking a sweat. Costs about $1,300 but comes with a 12-year warranty. The Wi-Fi monitoring is gimmicky though.
Stiebel Eltron Tempra 36 Plus (Electric)
Quietest unit I've installed ($950). Perfect for condos where you can't vent gas. Just make sure your panel can handle 150 amps. Skip this if you have an older fuse box.
EcoSmart ECO 36 (Electric)
Budget pick at $600. Works great for 1-2 bathroom homes. The plastic housing feels cheap but it's lasted 5 years at my rental property. Just clean the filters monthly.
Permitting Hell: Navigating Local Codes
Almost forgot this nightmare part. Installing a tankless water heater usually requires:
- Plumbing permit ($75-$150)
- Electrical permit ($50-$100)
- Gas line permit (if applicable, $100+)
Your inspector will check:
- Vent pipe clearances (gas models)
- Earthquake strapping (California and seismic zones)
- Drain pan installation (required in finished spaces)
Pro tip: Schedule inspections for Monday mornings. Inspectors are less grumpy before their coffee wears off.
Maintenance: Skip This and Pay Later
These aren't install-and-forget appliances. Forget annual flushing and you'll be replacing that $800 heat exchanger by year 3. Here's my bare minimum maintenance routine:
- Monthly: Check error codes, clean inlet filter (takes 2 minutes)
- Every 6 months: Test pressure relief valve
- Annual: Chemical flush ($150 if hired out)
The vinegar flush process:
- Shut off water/power
- Connect submersible pump to service valves
- Circulate 4 gallons white vinegar for 45 minutes
- Flush with clean water
Honestly? Pay a pro the $150. Spilled vinegar smells worse than cat pee and the pumps cost $80.
When Installing Goes Wrong: Horror Stories
My worst installation disaster involved a client who ignored the venting requirements. Tried to vent a gas unit with PVC pipe (big no-no). Carbon monoxide detectors woke them at 3 AM. $3,000 later after emergency HVAC service and proper stainless steel venting... Moral? Don't cut corners.
Other common screwups:
- Using standard pipe dope instead of heat-resistant sealant (hello leaks!)
- Undersizing gas lines causing flame failure
- Ignoring hard water - scale buildup murders efficiency
Should You DIY or Hire a Pro?
Let's be brutally honest:
| Scenario | DIY Possible? | Professional Cost Range |
|---|---|---|
| Electric swap in same location | Yes* (if experienced with wiring) | $900-$1,500 |
| Gas conversion from tank heater | No | $2,200-$4,000 |
| New construction install | Maybe | $1,500-$2,500 |
*Electric DIY only if:
- No panel upgrade needed
- You own pipe crimpers
- You know how to pressure test
Pro tip: Get 3 quotes. I've seen identical jobs quoted at $1800 and $4200. The highballers prey on homeowners who don't know better.
Your Burning Questions Answered
Can I install a tankless water heater myself to save money?
Technically yes, practically no for most people. Unless you're comfortable sweating pipes and running 240v circuits, you'll regret it. That $1,500 you saved? It'll vanish when you flood the basement.
Why does my new unit keep shutting off during showers?
Probably flow sensor issues. Tankless heaters need minimum flow (usually 0.5 GPM). Sediment buildup tricks the sensor. Try cleaning the filter or increasing water pressure slightly.
Is tankless really cheaper long-term?
Math time: If your current tank heater costs $550/year to run and tankless costs $250, you save $300 annually. With install costs around $3k, you'll break even in 10 years. Worth it for longevity and endless showers? Absolutely.
Do I need a water softener?
If your water hardness exceeds 7 grains per gallon? 100% yes. Hard water scales units faster than you'd believe. Softener adds $600-$1500 but prevents $800 service calls later.
What's the biggest mistake people make when installing tankless water heaters?
Underestimating gas line requirements. Gas units need massive BTU delivery. That half-inch line servicing your old tank heater? Won't cut it. Expect to run new 1-inch piping.
The Verdict: Is It Worth Installing a Tankless Water Heater?
After helping with 50+ installations? Yes - if:
- You're remodeling anyway (easier retrofits)
- Your current heater is dying (avoid emergency premiums)
- You have medium-hard water (install conditioner!)
- Hate cold showers during family visits
Just budget properly. The $1,000 units need $2,000 in supporting infrastructure. But waking up to endless hot water never gets old.
Leave a Message