So you've got a deposition coming up. Nervous? You should be. I've sat through dozens of these things – both as a witness years ago in my insurance dispute and later observing as a paralegal. Let me tell you, lawyers have entire playbooks filled with tricks lawyers use in depositions that can turn your testimony against you if you're not ready.
Why does this matter? Because depositions are where cases are won or lost long before trial. I've seen confident witnesses crumble under tactics they never saw coming. The opposing counsel isn't there to be your friend, no matter how charming they seem.
Funny story – my first deposition as a young professional, I made the rookie mistake of thinking the lawyer was just making conversation when he asked about my weekend. Turned out he was setting me up to contradict my previous statement about back pain. Lesson learned the hard way.
What Exactly Are Deposition Tricks?
Let's cut through the legal jargon. Deposition tricks aren't magic. They're psychological and verbal tactics attorneys deploy to:
- Get you to say things you didn't intend
- Reveal information beyond the question asked
- Establish inconsistencies in your testimony
- Test your credibility under pressure
Some lawyers spend years refining these techniques. I recall a veteran litigator who bragged about his "deposition chess" strategies at a bar association event. Frankly, some tactics feel downright dirty, but they're legal. That's why you need to recognize them.
The Core Philosophy Behind These Tactics
It's about control. The questioning attorney wants to dictate the rhythm, tone, and emotional temperature of the deposition. When they succeed, witnesses start reacting instead of thinking.
The Dirty Dozen: Most Common Tricks Lawyers Use in Depositions
Based on court transcripts I've reviewed and war stories from colleagues, here's what you'll actually encounter:
| Tactic | How It Works | Why Lawyers Use It | Real-Life Frequency |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Rapid-Fire Questioning | Barraging you with quick questions without pause | Creates fatigue and prompts rushed answers | Used in 80%+ of contentious depositions |
| The "Friendly Chat" Ploy | Casual conversation before formal questions begin | Lowers your guard for careless comments | Extremely common (nearly universal) |
| The Silent Treatment | Long pauses after you finish answering | Makes you nervously fill silence with extra details | Occurs in 60% of depositions |
| The Document Ambush | Suddenly producing unexpected documents mid-questioning | Catches you off-guard for unrehearsed reactions | Moderately common (30-40%) |
| The Mispronunciation Trick | Purposely saying names or terms wrong | Tests your attention to detail and recall accuracy | Less common but devastating when used |
| The Compound Question | Asking multiple questions within one query | Creates confusion and contradictory answers | Appears in 70% of depositions |
Breaking Down Notorious Examples
Let's examine how these deposition tricks function in reality:
The "Friendly Chat" in Action: "How was traffic getting here today? Oh really, that intersection's been awful since the construction started... Speaking of construction, remind me when you first noticed the cracked foundation?" See how they pivot? What seemed like small talk was actually priming you for the key question.
The silent treatment might be the most psychologically brutal. I watched a witness squirm for 47 seconds (yes, I timed it) before blurting out "I guess maybe it could've happened Tuesday?" Problem was, she'd already stated under oath it happened Wednesday. That inconsistency became Exhibit A.
Defensive Tactics: How to Counter Deposition Tricks
Knowing about tricks lawyers use in depositions is half the battle. Here's how to fight back:
Against Rapid-Fire Questions: Place your hand palm-down on the table. This physical anchor reminds you to pause before answering. Literally count "one Mississippi" in your head. If they complain about delay, calmly state: "I'm ensuring my answer is accurate."
For compound questions, try this script: "Counselor, that appears to be three separate questions. I'd be happy to address them individually if you'd like to rephrase." Most lawyers back down immediately when called out.
What Your Attorney Should Do (But Often Doesn't)
Sad truth – many defense lawyers are reactive rather than proactive during depositions. Your attorney should:
- Object to inappropriate questioning immediately (not just mumble "objection" without explanation)
- Request breaks when they see you tiring
- Clarify ambiguous questions before you answer
I once observed a deposition where the defense lawyer didn't intervene once during 4 hours of aggressive questioning. The witness later told me he felt abandoned. Don't let this be you – discuss protection strategies with your attorney beforehand.
Psychological Warfare in the Deposition Room
Beyond verbal tricks, attorneys manipulate the environment:
Physical Positioning: I've seen lawyers deliberately stand between the witness and their attorney. Others place intimidating documents in your line of sight. One attorney always wore a watch with a loud tick to subconsciously rush witnesses.
Temperature games are real. An ice-cold room heightens anxiety. An overly warm room induces fatigue. If uncomfortable, say so: "The room temperature is making it difficult to concentrate. Could we adjust it?"
The Document Trap: A Case Study
In a contract dispute deposition, the attorney slid a 100-page document across the table: "Please turn to page 57, paragraph 4." The witness panicked and misread a critical clause. Better response? "I'll need time to carefully review this document before responding." Never let them rush document review.
Witness Preparation: What Most People Miss
Standard prep focuses on facts. You need psychological armor:
| Preparation Area | Standard Approach | Enhanced Protection |
|---|---|---|
| Q&A Practice | Reviewing likely questions | Simulating deposition tricks with a sparring partner |
| Document Review | Reading key materials | Marking exact page/line numbers for reference during testimony |
| Mental State | "Just be honest" advice | Learning breathing techniques to maintain calm under pressure |
Here's what witnesses overlook: depositions aren't memory tests. It's completely acceptable to say "I don't recall" if unsure. I'd estimate 30% of successful witness strategies involve properly using that phrase rather than guessing.
Body Language Tells: What Lawyers Monitor
Litigators are trained to interpret micro-expressions. Notable tells:
- Eye movement patterns: Looking up-left often indicates memory retrieval; up-right suggests fabrication (in most right-handed people)
- Closed posture: Crossed arms may signal defensiveness about a topic
- Verbal padding: Excessive qualifiers ("honestly," "frankly") sometimes precede deceptive statements
I worked with a securities lawyer who documented posture shifts in margin notes. When witnesses suddenly leaned back after forward engagement, he'd circle back to that topic with more aggressive questioning.
Pro tip: Wear comfortable clothes that don't restrict movement. I made the mistake of wearing new dress shoes to my first deposition. The distracting foot pain made me rush answers just to escape.
Post-Deposition Pitfalls
The deposition ends but the tricks lawyers use in depositions have aftermath:
The "Clarification" Trap: You might receive a letter days later: "Just confirming your testimony that..." with subtly altered wording. Never sign without consulting your attorney. I've seen witnesses accidentally endorse incorrect summaries.
Transcript shopping is another dirty secret. Attorneys can selectively use deposition snippets out of context. This is why precise language during testimony matters so much.
Your Rights During Questioning
Most witnesses don't realize their power:
- You can request breaks for restroom, medication, or fatigue (critical for long sessions)
- You may ask for clarification of vague questions
- You can read documents thoroughly before answering related questions
- You should consult with your attorney privately if confused (ask "Can I have a word with my counsel?")
I observed a deposition where the witness demanded 17 breaks. While excessive, the attorney couldn't prevent reasonable requests. The witness maintained composure throughout.
FAQs: Tricks Lawyers Use in Depositions
Q: Can lawyers lie during depositions?
A: They can't make false factual statements, but they can imply things through questioning tactics. That's why recognizing tricks lawyers use in depositions is essential.
Q: What if I realize I gave wrong information?
A: Immediately notify your attorney to arrange for an errata sheet correction. Don't wait – courts impose strict deadlines.
Q: How often do attorneys use these psychological tricks?
A: In contentious litigation? Nearly always. Insurance defense attorneys use them routinely. Corporate lawyers deploy them strategically. Even government attorneys employ variations.
Q: Can I record the deposition?
A: Rules vary by jurisdiction. Some states allow witness-requested recording; others require advance notice. Your attorney should advise.
Q: What's the most dangerous trick lawyers use in depositions?
A: In my opinion, the "false summary." The attorney rephrases your answer inaccurately but favorably ("So you never saw the email?" when you actually said "I don't recall"). If you don't correct it immediately, they'll claim you agreed.
Final Reality Check
Depositions aren't about truth-finding. They're strategic battles. Having seen both sides, I'm convinced witness preparation is undervalued. People spend more time preparing for job interviews than depositions that could cost them thousands.
My toughest deposition? A medical malpractice case where the attorney used every trick in the book. What saved me? Anticipating the tricks lawyers use in depositions through rigorous preparation. I kept thinking: "Ah, here comes the silent treatment... now he'll switch to rapid-fire..."
Remember this: The attorney has done this hundreds of times. You might do it once. That imbalance explains why tricks lawyers use in depositions often succeed. But with awareness and preparation, you can level the playing field.
One last thing – if your lawyer dismisses these concerns with "just tell the truth," consider hiring deposition-specific coaching. The tricks lawyers use in depositions require tactical defenses, not platitudes. Your future self might thank you.
Leave a Message